Curved screen vs sphrical screen (partial dome)

7 replies [Last post]

 Greetings,

 I'm new to this forum. I'm currently building a 767 sim and have been waiting until the cockpit is near completion before attempting the visuals. My plan is to build either a curve ( 6 foot radius) or a spherical type as seen in NThusim Test Rig. My apologies if this has already been answered before.  Aside from the building difficulty , can someone say if there would there be a noticable difference having the spherical screen over the curved screen. 

Thanks,

Mike

I would recommend making a cylindrical screen, at least at first. Spherical screens are definitely harder to make.

But to answer your question, spherical does have a visual advantage in that it can make it harder for the brain to locate the screen. Due to the second curvature, you can struggle to establish at what distance the screen is.

The visual advantage of a cylindrical screen over a flat screen is a huge. But the advantage of a spherical screen over a cylindrical screen has a much lower reward:pain ratio.

Yep, with circular screen you can jump right in quick with the build and do it dirt cheap. My particular screen is two raw canvas drop cloths for $20 each and four pieces for 12 foot long 1x1" plastic trim. Working out the complex curvature of a cylindrical screen isn't an easy project. I'm assuming they're mostly pre-built kits you can get though. I'd not want to do a DIY screen like that unless I was really good with sowing multiple arcs of screen material in a consistant manner.

 What I had in mind was using flexible sheets of eva (running shoe mid sole material) , cutting the edges some number of degrees off parallel and gluing the seems with barge glue. I have an edge joiner to adjust the edges for the correct number of degrees .


  I would build a rigid frame that used perhaps a 7 foot radius upper and middle rim and perhaps 6 foot lower rim. Any imperfections, say at the seams could be sanded or shaved with a hand plane .

Not sure how it would come out, but the first thing I would need to know is if EVA is good projection surface. I do have some sheets in my shop and DLP projector, so I would experiment first. Perhaps if that works then I would see how well the joining worked.

 We shall see.  As it is, I'm open to all possibilities. 

Thanks very much for all the suggestions and advice.

Please post any findings, I for one would be interested what you find out!

Agreed, don't be afraid of DIY and documenting it here. More options the better when it comes to screen ideas. I'd do some projection material tests before I got too far though. Make sure the material isn't too glossy. If it is, you'll get hot spots in your projection, which will blow out the bright areas. Projection must always be mindful of the dark shadowy areas and the bright areas of the projection and seek a material that balances those to look good.

 I do have options on material color.  As it is, e.v.a. material is porous but very smooth. A white sheet is definately not shiney. I have a brown and white sheet to experiment with. I'll post my findings.

Sounds very interesting, we're looking forward to the results!

Customize This